How Managers Can Support Staff Facing Medical Legal Challenges

14 January 2026

How Managers Can Support Staff Facing Medical Legal Challenges

Experiencing medical malpractice can be both emotionally draining and physically damaging for anyone. However, when you are a manager, the challenge can be twofold: perhaps navigating your own recovery while also understanding how to support staff who might be facing similar professional and personal crises. When an employee has put their entire trust into a healthcare professional, it is extremely disheartening when things go wrong. Consequently, the situation will undoubtedly cause significant pain, upset, and possible a noticeable drop in workplace engagement. For a leader, this isn’t just a personal tragedy; it is a sensitive management issue that requires empathy, clarity, and a strong overarching strategy.

Because the path to recovery is often long, understanding the nuances of the healthcare and legal systems is vital for both you and your team. To give you a grounding in the basics, here are several essential things you should know about managing this difficult journey, whether you are the one affected or you are guiding a colleague through the process.

1. Distinguishing Malpractice from Unfortunate Outcomes

First off, it’s highly important to have a thorough understanding of what malpractice actually is. Just because a team member has experienced a result they don’t like doesn’t necessarily mean the medical professional was at fault. Medical procedures are inherently complicated, and not every bad outcome is the result of negligence.

Malpractice specifically occurs when a healthcare professional fails to meet an accepted standard of care. This means their actions deviated from what a competent peer would have done in the same situation. As such, it’s usually a term reserved for negligence with diagnosis, errors in surgery, or mistakes with medication. To have a successful claim, one will need to prove that here was a clear breach of care. Therefore, helping an employee distinguish between a “known risk” and “negligence” can be the first step in managing their expectations.

2. The Power of Meticulous Documentation

Documenting the entire event is essential if an individual is going to make a claim or seek an internal review. You should encourage the affected person to preserve and back up all physical and digital documents, such as medical records and test results. Additionally, they should save every email or letter between them and the medical team involved.

At the same time, keeping records of how the injury is affecting daily life is crucial. Because memories fade over time, journal notes expressing feelings can help a person articulate themselves more clearly later. Make sure they take pictures of injuries if they’re visible, as visual evidence is often very compelling. Furthermore, as a manager, you can assist by providing accurate records of any sick leave or loss of earnings. This level of detail is exactly what a legal team will need to quantify losses effectively.

3. Securing Expert Legal Representation

When it comes to receiving legal support, one shouldn’t just go with any general solicitor. Instead, it is vital to find someone who is specifically well-versed in clinical negligence. A qualified malpractice lawyer understands how to assess a case to see if it’s viable before guiding the claimant through the filing process. They’ll be able to help build a watertight case so that the individual receives the compensation they deserve.

It may also be appropriate to ask a lawyer about suing for emotional distress. Sometimes, the mental burden may be far greater than the physical injury itself. For instance, post-traumatic stress following a medical error can severely impact a staff member’s ability to perform their duties. Consequently, a specialist lawyer will ensure these “non-economic” damages are factored into any settlement. They often work on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis, which can ease the financial pressure on an employee during a crisis.

4. Understanding the Statute of Limitations

Lastly, it’s important to remember that there are strict time limits for taking action, called the statute of limitations. If a person waits too long, they might lose their right to seek compensation, even if they have a very strong case. In the UK, the general rule is that a claimant has three years from the date of the injury or the date they became aware of it. However, these rules can vary significantly if dealing with international jurisdictions or specific US states.

Because of these deadlines, it is helpful to encourage the affected party to act as quickly as possible. Waiting for an internal hospital investigation to finish can sometimes eat up precious time. Therefore, it’s wise to seek preliminary legal advice while the internal review is still ongoing. By staying ahead of the clock, the employee ensures their rights remain protected throughout the entire process.

5. Managing the Professional Impact

As a manager, dealing with a medical crisis—whether your own or a subordinate’s—presents unique challenges. You may find that focus is fractured or that physical limitations prevent the performance of usual duties. Nevertheless, it is important to communicate with the HR department early on. Being transparent about the situation can help in securing necessary adjustments to the workload or flexible working hours.

Furthermore, you should lean on the wider support network within the organisation. Delegating tasks to trusted team members not only helps the person in recovery but also empowers the rest of the staff to step up. Although it’s tempting for high-achievers to “power through,” taking the time to heal properly is the most professional path. By managing recovery as effectively as any other project, you ensure a smoother transition back to full productivity.

6. Seeking Support Beyond the Legalities

While the legal and financial aspects are important, mental well-being is paramount. Many people find that talking to a therapist or joining a support group for victims of medical error is incredibly helpful. These spaces allow individuals to process the trauma without the pressure of “fixing” everything immediately.

Additionally, organizations like Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA) provide free independent advice and support for patients. They can help navigate the NHS complaints procedure or find specialized solicitors. Similarly, in the US, the National Patient Safety Foundation offers resources to help patients understand their rights. Utilizing these authoritative sources will give any manager the confidence to provide the right guidance to their team.

Wrapping Up

Hopefully, you’re now a little clearer on the core elements of dealing with medical malpractice and how to support those affected by it. As a manager, your role is not to be a legal expert, but to provide the stable environment and informed encouragement your staff need during a vulnerable time. It won’t be easy, but if you take things one step at a time and lean on the right professional resources, your team can recover effectively. By fostering a culture of support and practical action, you help ensure that a personal medical crisis doesn’t become a career-ending event. Good luck!

Header Image by Megan Rexazin Conde from Pixabay

References and Further Reading

• AvMA (Action against Medical Accidents) – The UK’s leading charity for patient safety and justice.

• Citizens Advice: NHS Complaints – Authoritative UK guidance on how to complain about medical treatment.

• The Center for Justice & Democracy – A US-based non-profit providing extensive research on medical malpractice and consumer rights.

• The General Medical Council (GMC) – Information on the standards expected of doctors in the UK and how to report concerns.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. Laws regarding medical malpractice vary by jurisdiction. You should consult with a qualified legal professional or healthcare provider regarding your specific situation before taking any action.

Header

More career development tools and thought-provokers!

In these trying times, your next big career move may have been forced on you. If so, you might find some helpful tips in our article: Dealing with Job Loss: Survive and Thrive with ‘Plan A’. Or for more career development resources look at our great-value guides. These include some excellent tools to help your personal development plan. The best-value approach is to buy our Personal Development bundle, available from the store.

We’ve bundled together these five e-guides at half the normal price! Read the guides in this order, and use the tools in each, and you’ll be well on your way to achieving your personal development plan. (5 guides, 125 pages, 26 tools, for half price!)

Manage Your Own Performance (28 pages, 6 tools)
Managers Make the Difference (27 pages, 5 tools)
Managing from Strength to Strength (22 pages, 5 tools)
Making Change Personal (22 pages, 5 tools)
Re-defining Middle Management (26 pages, 5 tools)

>> Return to the Personal Development Knowledge Hub